Video 5. Big Bang vs. the Law of Conservation of Matter.

Video 5. Big Bang vs. the Law of Conservation of Matter

Article:

Evolution is can be described as a complete path over 7 epochs, days or stages. In this article we’re looking at the beginning day, cosmic evolution: how the universe, and the matter in it, came to be. Take a look at the sources I use at the end. Then I’ll compare the materialist evolution account with one of the best-tested laws in all of science: the Law of Conservation of Matter.

Cosmic Evolution’s Claim

Cosmic evolution, the Big Bang and other creation accounts of the universe, says the matter of our universe was created in the Big Bang or inflation. For simplicity purposes, allow me to use ‘big bang’ as a place holder or primary explanation for all creation hypothesis. You can read about other creation hypotheses at Space.com’s article: “Alternatives to the Big Bang Theory”.

On the other hand, the Law of Conservation of Matter says matter cannot be created or destroyed by natural processes, and its modern form says the same of energy. If both are true, where did the matter or the energy come from?

Given

  • All scientific laws and theories must be compatible. Two that are incompatible mean that one or both are incorrect.
  • “Evolution” is used here in its broad sense, which includes cosmic evolution, not only Darwin’s biological evolution.
  • The Law of Conservation of Matter (mass) has been confirmed in every experiment ever performed on it.

Definitions

Evolution (broad sense). Today the word “evolution” is used far beyond Darwin’s biological evolution. It is applied to cosmic, galactic, stellar, planetary, chemical and organic change, which together are often presented as one continuous chain of development from the Big Bang to life today. The National Academy of Sciences notes this broader use in its book Science and Creationism (read it here):

Notice what the Academy adds: the processes involved are “quite different.” I agree, and that is exactly why each kind of evolution has to be checked against the natural laws on its own. In this video, we check cosmic evolution.

One could call it a grand cosmological continuum of different evolution. For this discussion, the question is the first link in that chain: how did matter come to exist at all?

Law of Conservation of Mass (Matter). The Law of Conservation of Mass states that in a closed system, mass is neither created nor destroyed. It can be rearranged into different particles or chemicals, but the mass at the beginning always equals the mass at the end.

Einstein refined this law. He showed that mass and energy are interchangeable (E = mc²), so modern physics speaks of the conservation of mass-energy. Matter can become energy, and energy can become matter, but the total is never created or destroyed. The First Law of Thermodynamics says the same about energy.

The Big Bang (as cosmologists describe it). The Big Bang theory says the universe began about 13.8 billion years ago in an extremely hot, dense state and has been expanding ever since. Cosmologists generally describe this as an expansion of space itself rather than an explosion in space, although popular articles, including the one we’re about to read, often call it an explosion. Explosion or expansion, the end result was the creation of the cosmos over a period of time; quick or gradual.

Discussion

1. Matter may seem to disappear, but it does not

As you know, matter can be a solid, a liquid or a gas, and it can change from one to another. You see this in everyday life:

  • When highway crews in Florence Oregon blew up a dead whale on the beach in 1970, the whale did not disappear. It rained down on the onlookers. Many onlookers who had parked close experience car damage.(Click here to read the article.)
  • Water may seem to disappear from your kitchen sponge, but it has only evaporated into the air.
  • Sugar may seem to disappear in your hot tea, but it has only dissolved. You can still taste it.
  • A burning candle’s wax may seem to disappear, but it becomes carbon dioxide and water vapor. (Click here to see how matter changes.)
  • When substances react to make new substances, the old ones may seem to disappear, but every atom is still there.

In every case, the mass before equals the mass after.

2. What one cosmology article says

In “Big Bang Theory: Evolution of Our Universe,” Matthew Williams of Universe Today (republished by Phys.org, December 2015) writes that the universe was created in a massive explosion that “not only created the majority of matter” but also the physical laws that govern it. Here is a clip; see the blue highlight:

Now, I’ve got to stay calm, because under the conservation laws, neither matter nor energy can create itself. Yet this article tells us an explosion created the matter. And I haven’t even gotten into what an explosion requires; that’s for another video. Today we’re only talking about conservation.

Wait a minute. The article says the “majority” of matter. Stop the presses! Where did the rest come from? A cosmologist would say heavier elements were built later inside stars. But building elements in stars only rearranges matter that already existed, and conservation allows that. It doesn’t tell us where the first matter came from.

So you have a choice. You can accept that an explosion simply occurred and produced the matter of the universe. Or you can go with the natural laws, which say matter and energy cannot create themselves. If the laws are right, the explanation by cosmic evolutionist needs to be a good deal better than that.

3. The best explanation offered

Even cosmologists admit the origin of matter is a puzzle. Here is how Live Science explains it:

“Initially, the universe was permeated only by energy. Some of this energy congealed into particles, which assembled into light atoms like hydrogen and helium.”

Notice what this explanation does. It doesn’t create matter from nothing. It turns energy into matter, which Einstein showed is possible. So the question moves back one step: where did the energy come from? Conservation of energy says energy can’t be created either.

Physicists also study what they call “mass generation mechanisms”: theories of how fundamental particles acquire mass under the laws of physics. The best known, the Higgs mechanism, was supported by the discovery of the Higgs boson in 2012. But it explains why particles have mass, not where the matter and energy of the universe came from in the first place. On that deeper question, physicists have proposed a number of models, and none is settled.

Whichever website you go to, the answer is the same: no one knows how the matter and energy of our universe came to be. The question “How did matter come into existence?” remains unanswered.

4. More questions

Cosmologists describe the early universe as extremely small, hot and dense. If so, more questions follow:

  • How did that first matter and energy come into existence?
  • How did it become today’s vast universe?
  • Where did the dark matter come from? By cosmologists’ own estimates, it outweighs ordinary matter about five to one.

Conflict

Here is the conflict. The Law of Conservation of Mass, and its broader form, conservation of mass-energy, says that matter and energy cannot be created or destroyed by natural processes. Cosmic evolution says the matter of the universe was created in the Big Bang. When pressed, it traces that matter back to energy whose origin no one can explain.

This is more than a gap in our knowledge. For matter and energy to come into existence by natural processes would require exactly what the conservation laws say never happens. A law and a theory that conflict cannot both be correct.

Do you see the conflict? If mass cannot create itself, how was the mass of the universe created?

Conclusion

How does this show that the theory of evolution is a failed theory?

Cosmic evolution can’t scientifically demonstrate or explain how matter came into existence. Its best account turns energy into matter, but it has no natural explanation for where that energy came from, and the conservation laws say nature can’t produce it. A theory that can’t be reconciled with one of the most thoroughly tested laws in science has failed that test.

Cosmic evolution is presented as the first link in the evolutionary chain. If the first link fails, the chain has nothing to hang from.

Harry’s Engineering Logic Check

CheckFinding
Law testedConservation of mass (in its modern form, conservation of mass-energy) and the First Law of Thermodynamics.
What the theory needsThe matter of the universe, or the energy it came from, must have come into existence by natural processes.
What the law allowsMatter and energy can be rearranged or converted into each other. The total cannot be created or destroyed.
Best available explanationEnergy turned into matter. Where the energy came from is not explained.
Does the theory fit the law?No. No law-abiding natural process can supply the first matter or energy.

If it doesn’t fit, you must acquit.

Sources

Scroll to Top