Video 3. Can Evolution Survive the Laws of Nature?

3. Introduction – Can Evolution Survive a Engineer’s Audit and Conflict with Laws of Nature?

Can a scientific theory conflict with a law of nature and still be true? That is the question behind this channel. My name is Harry Farrar. I’m a retired professional civil engineer, and I used to believe in evolution. On this channel, I’m going to compare evolution, claim by claim, against the laws of nature — the same physical laws and logic that I relied on throughout my career designing roads, sewer systems, foundations, bridges, stormwater systems, and potable water projects.

I have two reasons for doing this. The first one comes from a swimming pool.

When I was in high school, I was life guard and a water safety instructor for the Red Cross. Part of my job was teaching children to float on their backs. Most of them caught on quickly, but every so often I’d get a spirited child who was convinced he simply couldn’t float.

One boy told me flat out, “I can’t float.” That was all there was to it. I told him, “Oh, you can float. It’s really quite simple.” He didn’t believe me.

I could see what the problem was and it was common among those who couldn’t float. In the shallow end, this child kept fighting the water, trying to keep his feet on the bottom. So I said, “Let’s go out to the deeper end. You can float out there.”

“Oh no, I can’t float out there.”

“Sure you can,” I said. “It’s easy out there and there is a good reason; there’s more water to hold you up.” He was puzzled and I did not hesitate. Fortunately, he did not question me or know anything about the law of buoyancy.

We went out to the deeper end, I leaned him back, his feet came off of the pool bottom and he floated. The problem had never been the water. It was all in his head.

Here’s the interesting part: what I told him wasn’t actually true. In fact, it was a lie. The law of buoyancy says you are held up by the water you displace, not by how deep the water is beneath you. He would have floated just as well in the shallow end. If he had understood the law of buoyancy, he never would have accepted my explanation. But I was the authority figure, so he believed me.

That taught me something I’ve never forgotten. Authority figures sometimes tell us things that aren’t true for a variety of reasons, and we believe them because of who is saying them. A law of nature, however, doesn’t change depending on who the authority is.

My second reason is personal. In high school, I believed in evolution. The authorities taught it, it made perfect sense, and honestly, I liked it. If I was simply a product of evolution, then I wasn’t really accountable for a lot of things. It wasn’t my fault — it was just part of me evolving.

That belief changed 180 degrees when I got to engineering school and began learning the laws of nature. The first big awareness that I experienced was when the thermodynamic professor explained entropy. The eye opener was that heat flows one direction. This begged the questions, 1) how did all of that heat get organized into stars of the universe only to send the heat outward and 2) where did the heat come from? As time passed, I learned about more laws of nature and laws of philosophy (logic).

Later, as a design engineer on roadway, sewer, water, and other civil projects, I didn’t just study those laws — I had to work with them every day. Every design had to fit them. A design that conflicts with a law of nature fails. The law of non-contradiction says the same thing. If two laws, theories, anythings conflict, one or both are incorrect.

So where do I stand today? I used to believe in evolution. Now I don’t. I believe in science.

Here’s what this channel will cover, and what it won’t. We won’t be discussing probability, fossils, historical observations, biblical accuracy, biology, astronomy, or chemistry and so much more that is covered on the internet. Instead, we’ll stick to the laws of nature — the ones you already know and rely on every day. From here we ask one simple question: Does evolution actually fit the laws of nature? I have listed those laws of nature here.

Because if it doesn’t fit; there is a conflict, one or both are wrong.

Thanks for watching my videos and this website as we audit and examine the theory of biological and cosmic evolution in light of the laws of nature. I look forward to working through these laws with you in the videos ahead.

Scroll to Top