
There are two types of events that we are concerned with: past and present. You hope for and anticipate a future event but let me set that aside. Science is based on present events because you can reproduce them. A historic event is not a scientific event. It is becomes a legal event to determine what happened in the past using science to help explain it.
Now, you were introduced to that legal system when you pushed your brother over. Pushed him down. Yeah. Now, I know that because I pushed my brother down, and I went to court over my action, like you probably did, too. The court I’m referring to is your mother, trying to come up with a hypothesis with a high degree of probability on how things happened as she gathered evidence.
When I was a physics lab assistant, we performed present events. Then the students would write a report explaining the laws of nature and what they saw. These where scientific events – present events if you will. When you drive your car, you are in a present event. And if you have an accident, you are in a present event.
Am I clear on the differences? Science or operational events are repeatable and are resolved by the scientific method. Historic or legal events cannot be repeated so they are resoled in a “court”. This could be a court of law, a corporate conference room, or around the family pool. The historic event is always resolved using a legal system debate with a degree of probability. Historic events cannot be “proven true”, they can only be demonstrated accurate with a degree of probability.
While the car crash happened in the now. What happens after the accident? Someone hit someone else. Why? How? Who was careless? All involved want to know what happened making this present event a future past event that will be examined in detail.
Police look at evidence to determine who is at fault. They take picture, draw sketches, obtain witness statements, gather video data, etc. Prayerfully there is little physical damage. Someone may go to the emergency room. Doctors run test on the victim to document damages and treatment.
Fast forward. The lawyers come in to settle claims. They look at the documentation and hire experts to present evidence supporting their side of the legal claim.
This car accident is not a present event. It is now a past event. Each legal team will present their argument on what happened in the past event, presenting their side of the event because we know that there are two sides to every story. They will present pictures, sketches, eye witness accounts, and experts like forensic engineers, design engineers, traffic engineers, anatomy engineers for whiplash, etc.
Am I making my point? The car accident is a past event where physical evidence and science experts are brought in to explain it. Think about any murder trial you have seen on TV. Same thing. The trial to explain what happened is not a scientific event. It is a legal event to determined what happened in the past using science to help explain it.
Now let us look at another past event – evolution. Let me read something that I picked up from University of California at Berkley. It comes from Understanding Evolution, a site run by the UC Museum of Paleontology at Berkeley, https://evolution.berkeley.edu/lines-of-evidence/ “ At the heart of evolution theory are the basic ideas that life has changed over time and that different species share common ancestors.” You and I know that animals adapt to their environment. But I see this statement as a claim of speciation – new creatures being created. Which is a entirely different issue than adaptation.
Berkley goes on and states, “Overwhelming evidence supports these facts.” Evidence does not support facts. Evidence is usually a fact. Interpretations of facts or evidence presents a claim about the past with a degree of probability.
Now hold on… Evolution is not a scientific event. It is a legal event. In other words, it is a historic event that must be examined in the legal environment presenting evidence and concluding what happened with a degree of probability.
Unfortunately, evolution has no police records, no pictures, no video, no eye witnesses. However, there is a substantial amount of physical evidence for experts to examine and to present their interpretation of what happened.
Below is a list of evidence for biological evolution and its creation of new species:
- Fossils in rock layers to reveal organisms that appeared in the past.
- Bones in the rock layers to compare anatomy and physical features from different species.
- DNA in bones and teeth to compare closely related species.
- Biogeography around the globe to reveal distribution of plants and animals.
- Direct observation in laboratories to reveal small scale adaptation in real time.
There is no doubt about the above facts and that animals adapt to their environment. The claim by evolutionist and Berkley is different than adaptation; it is speciation (new creatures being created). The difficulty of claiming these facts prove new species are created is twofold. First, the interpretation of these facts to conclude speciation is a jump in logic – adaptation does not cause speciation. There is a video I made called “adaptation is not evolution” that goes into this.
Second, the lack of evidence that undermine that interpretation is not presented. This is only natural in a historical or legal debate but not is a scientific debate. An example of this is the abrupt appearance of vertebra animals in the fossil record. Another example of this is the challenge to generate brand-new functional biochemical systems or complex coded information which is covered in my “Archaeopteryx: Can Evolution Really Rewrite DNA?” video.
Evolutionist point out examples in the wild of evolution like Darwin’s finches’ changes in beaks, or Hawaiian crickets shifting to silent wings, or house sparrows becoming larger. These are all clear example of adaptation evolution. These are not examples of creating a new creature.
In summary, when trying to understand the past, we have a court system, from mom to supreme including peer review and public opinion. We need to realize that there are two sides to every story and each side is going to present their best case. Each side overlooks evidence that undermines their case. Each side is shooting for the highest probability to reduce reasonable doubt.
Now, this channel is not about evolution versus creation. It’s about science, and comparing evolution’s claims of past events with natural laws in a legal, evidence-based manner, and asking you to decide your findings.
