Video 4. Can Something Create Itself? NASA, what say you?

Now, “evolution” is a series of events that occurred over epochs of time to bring us from the very beginning to humans on this planet. We want to examine one of these epochs called cosmic evolution. I start with NASA’s Space Place:

“The big bang is how astronomers explain the way the universe began. It is the idea that the universe began as just a small point, then expanded and stretched to grow as large as it is right now. And it is still stretching.”

Another quote from NASA can be found at their Cosmic Inflation website which says: “Around 13.8 billion years ago, the universe expanded faster than the speed of light for a fraction of a second, a period called cosmic inflation. Scientists aren’t sure what came before inflation or what powered it.”

So that is what cosmic evolution says according to NASA. What I want to ask you is: what do the natural laws say about cosmic evolution? Specifically, the law of causality: every effect we see has a cause.

I wonder what caused the effect we observe from that small point of singularity – the expanding universe, the stretching universe. What caused that? (Let me set aside the question of where did the point of singularity come from.)

It’s easy to just say, “Oh, it happened.” But we can think scientifically. I believe in science. I want to know what the cause was, and I hope you want to know what the cause was also.

As an engineer, I want to know the reality of the event. So, let me put NASA’s explanation (and so many others) in a real life situation. But before I do, I don’t mean to pick on NASA. I believe in cosmological and biological evolution. I believed authorities like NASA, science teachers, science text books, Carl Sagan, Stephen Hawking, Stephen Jay Gould, Richard Dawkins and the list goes on. I believe Georges Lemaitre’s big bang hypothesis and the entire scientific community’s materialistic explanation of the beginning of time and how this universe evolved.

Please understand that I am not claiming to know how the beginning occurred nor how singularity inflated, expanded, or evolved into the universe that the James Webb Space Telescope sees today. But cosmic evolution is not compatible with the laws of nature. Is the scientific community telling me the whole story? Maybe they should admit that their cosmic evolution story is a speculative hypothesis rather than a scientific fact like Stephen Jay Gould wrote in his 1981 essay, “Evolution as fact and theory,”

Picture a real world scene. You are at a pool table with your friends. One of them has racked the balls at one end of the table. Another friend is at the other end of the pool table with their pool cue. All of your friends know what is about to happen. Several laws of nature, including Newton’s laws of motion and the law of causality, are about to be All kinds of Newtonian laws and laws of nature are about to be demonstrated. The specific law of nature I am thinking about is the law of causality or cause and effect.

I love playing pool. My mental intention moves my arm that moves a stick that moves a white ball that moves colored balls, scattering them from a tight triangle across the table into pokets.  Pool combines cause and effect with Newton’s laws of motion.

Because we are human, when event B follows event A, we naturally wonder whether A caused B.

An example of this is the event of rain (A) followed by wet grass (B).  If we observe this with our senses each time and understand the reasons “wet grass” follows “rain” then we conclude that “wet grass” is the effect of “rain”. In other words, A (rain) caused B (wet grass).”

It is one thing to say that “nothing” moved the cue ball into motion to make the racked balls explode or inflate into motion; it happened by chance or it just happened.  It is another thing to say something moved them that I did not or could not see.

Another example of the law of causality is domino chain reaction.  In 2024, a team of more than 30 builders toppled nearly 900,000 dominoes with the touch of a single one.

Just one domino was the cause.  The effect was the was a domino chain reaction.   (Watch the fall here.)

Do you see the difference between “I don’t know what caused it” and “nothing caused it”?   “I don’t know” claims a lack of knowledge. “It created itself” claims total knowledge as Stephen Hawking expressed in The Grand Design, 2010: “Because there is a law such as gravity, the universe can and will create itself from nothing.”

From the law of causality we know that an effect has a cause.  Whether this is true before or at the moment time began we don’t know. But science can identify a probable cause from every effect it documents. The question between causes and effects revolve around our sense perception and our reasoning.  We must admit that our senses do not have perfect perception of reality. We have machines like microscopes and telescopes to heighten our senses. Even so, we cannot sense all of the unseen forces in action.

Given by definition: a “fact” is data and observable evidence, a “theory” is a well substantiated explanation, and that laws, facts and theories cannot conflict with each other (law of non-contradiction). So when a theory appears to conflict with a law of nature, which one gives way?

Do you see the conflicts between cosmic evolution’s claims and the laws of nature? I could be wrong, but I live in a reality that science has helped frame for me. I believe in science and the laws of nature. For me the theory of cosmic evolution is not a theory nor fact as so many experts claim. It may be a hypothesis. But I question that because claiming that chance, time, or the singularity itself caused the Big Bang seems to violate the law of causality.

How can the effect, the universe, cause itself?  I am not claiming to know how the beginning occurred but using the law of causality, there must have been a first cause. This seems well documented by Georges Lemaitre, Edwin Hubble, Stephen Hawking, Roger Penrose, Arvind Borde, and the list goes on. There was a “first cause” that made the universe explode, or expand or inflate into existence.  What was the first cause?  It was not a mathematical probability called chance.  Nor could it have been the singularity, since that is only the effect in condensed form. What caused the hot, dense beginning in the first place?

In summary, it seems that no one knows. And I can accept that no one knows. Cosmic evolutionist should use the word “hypothesis” rather than “theory” of “fact” among all of the other creation theories. I think that does a disservice to science.

Scroll to Top