Video 1. Can Nothing Explode into Something?

Can Nothing Explode, Evolve, or Inflate into Something? The Law of Identity vs. a Universe from Nothing?

First, can anything create itself? Set itself aside, you tell me, can nothing create anything? You pick the most reasonable cosmological explanation below.

In this short video I check the big bang or the universe from nothing claim against one of the most basic laws we have, the law of identity. The law of identity is a law of logic, and every law of nature depends on it. A theory that conflicts with it can’t be true. You know that any theory cannot be true if it conflicts with this law of logic.

Let us look at the below summary of what cosmic evolutionists say using some of the best-documented examples:

  1. Stephen Hawking and Leonard Mlodinow, The Grand Design (2010). The authors argue that because a law like gravity exists, “the universe can and will create itself from nothing.” Furthermore, they call spontaneous creation the reason anything exists at all.
  2. Lawrence Krauss, A Universe from Nothing (2012). The book argues that quantum physics allows a universe to arise from “nothing” with no cause or creator. Richard Dawkins wrote the afterword.
  3. Edward Tryon, “Is the Universe a Vacuum Fluctuation?” (Nature, 1973). Tryon proposed, in his original technical paper, that the universe began as a quantum fluctuation. He argued that its total energy may net to zero, so no energy had to come from anywhere.
  4. Alexander Vilenkin, “Creation of Universes from Nothing” (Physics Letters B, 1982). Vilenkin proposed quantum-cosmological model in which a universe could emerge through quantum-tunnel into existence from a state with no space, time, or matter.
  5. Alan Guth, inflation theory. Guth has repeatedly called the universe “the ultimate free lunch,” meaning it may have come into being at no net cost in energy.
  6. Peter Atkins, Creation Revisited (1992) and On Being (2011). Atkins, an Oxford chemist and an outspoken materialist, offered accounts of how a universe might arise without a creator, including ideas involving opposing quantities or a self-canceling process from absolute nothingwith no agent involved.
  7. NASA, Cosmic History. In NASA’s Cosmic Times 1955 NASA wrote: “We think that the universe began from nothing as a singularity about 15 billion years ago and has been expanding ever since.“” While NASA was clear in 1955. today NASA does not mention “nothing”. Its present website “Cosmic Inflation” says this about the universe’s beginning: “Around 13.8 billion years ago, the universe expanded faster than the speed of light for a fraction of a second, a period called cosmic inflation.” This webpage talked about the end of inflation and the beginning of the big bang: “When cosmic inflation stopped, the energy driving it transferred to matter and light – the big bang.” 

Regardless of a cosmologist’s hypothesis on the physics behind the above quotes, their direct or indirect claim is that the universe created itself from nothing; absolute philosophical nothingness. Our scientific question is: from what and with what force or cause did the universe come from nothing?

Throughout their hypotheses, cosmologists have part of the beginning correct. The universe began and they have a hypothetical cause for that beginning. The questions cosmologists are trying to answer are: 1) “What was the beginning state? 2) What caused the beginning state to change into the universe we see today?”

Cosmologists investigate questions such as what the early universe was like and how it developed. Some models also address whether there was a prior state or an ultimate beginning. My concern is that a model should explain not only a possible pathway to a universe, but also what the pathway begins with and what makes the transition possible.

Some people argue that no cosmologist has claimed that the universe came from nothing. The titles and statements listed above show that the phrase “from nothing” does appear in this discussion. But the word nothing may mean different things in different accounts. That difference needs to be made clear. Notice the underlines above. Below are some questions I have for the 6 cosmologist listed above:

  1. Hawking – What was present before the law of gravity existed? How can we have gravity without mass?
  2. Krauss – What was present before quantum physics allowed the universe to arise from nothing? How can we have quantum physics out of nothing?
  3. Tryon – What was present before the universe began as a quantum fluctuation? What fluctuated?
  4. Vilenkin – What was present to allow quantum-tunnel? Can tunneling occur with no space, time or matter?
  5. Guth – How could anything come into being freely? Can a free lunch just appear?
  6. Atkins – How could a self-canceling split occur from nothing? What part of nothing split?

Examine what the above authors begin with as their starting point when their hypothetical first cause occurred. They started with nothing just like Genesis says that God started with nothing. This seems to me to be identical claims – creation by God or physical processes; a beginning from nothing.

The authors and theories above offer different evolutionary pathways of how a universe might arise. My objection is that an account of a possible pathway does not necessarily explain why there is a pathway, or what makes it possible. I believe this leaves an important question unanswered: What explains the evolutionary transition from whatever the starting state was to the universe we observe?

We know the universe had a beginning, as the above authors hypothesized. Genesis claims that God began the universe. Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) is evidence that there was a beginning. Today’s cosmologist agree that the universe had a beginning.

The law of identity is a specific law of logic that I included in the laws of nature because fundamental to understanding physical science. It says that a thing is what it is. In other words A is A. Change is something that happens to a thing. Changing a thing from one identity (A-nothing) to another identity (B-inflating universe) requires a cause, effort or energy; a pathway First, with no thing, there is nothing there to change. Second, with no thing, there is nothing there to make a change.

Everything we discuss has an identity in the sense that it is what it is. The chair you sit in at dinner has the identity of a chair. It is made of wood, but it isn’t a tree. Gold is an element. It can become a ring with the help of a jeweler agent who changed it. The other way something changes its identity is by a non-agent outside force, like a tornado. Let me make this clear; nothing can change its identity without a separate and external causal agent or independent force shaping it.

So here’s the question I’m asking, and I think you should too: how does “nothing,” with no agent or outside force acting on it, change its own identity from nothing into a universe? The above authors listed pathways that “could” create the universe out of nothing. They have it partly correct by providing a path to the effect of having a universe. But they did not provide the force, cause, energy, or separate and external causal premise required to perform that overwhelming accomplishment.

Tell me in the comments. What force do you think changed the identity of the universe from nothing to what we see today. I hope you see that the law of identity conflicts with cosmologists’ evolution hypothesis.

Click Here for NASA’s 1955 document. See the top right block of the table on page 6.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top